Textual Analysis Lesson: Segregation: Past or Present?
Lesson Plan
Maniac Magee | 820L

- Learning Goal
- Use the Textual Analysis process to answer comprehension questions about a text.
- Duration
- Approximately 1 Day (25 minutes)
- Necessary Materials
Provided: “Segregation: Past or Present?” Reading Passage (Student Packet, pages 14-15), Textual Analysis Questions (Student Packet, page 16)
Not Provided: Maniac Magee by Jerry Spinelli
Before the Lesson: Read Chapters 15-21; Complete Student Packet Worksheets for Chapters 15-21
Activation and Motivation
Engage students in a discussion about the book, by asking them the following questions: "If you were Maniac Magee, would you travel between the East and West Ends of town? Why or why not? Would you be friends with someone like Maniac Magee, someone who doesn’t accept the social rules between groups of people?" Explain that the division of blacks and whites, or the West End and East End, plays a major role in Maniac Magee. The book brings to light segregation and how it impacts people and events in a community. Hand out the “Segregation: Past or Present?” Reading Passage to each student.
Before Reading
- Read the passage title, introduction, and any captions.
- Look at any pictures or photographs.
- Read the first two sentences only.
- Stop! Brainstorm what you think the text is going to be mostly about.
- Read and label the Textual Analysis questions with the appropriate skill/strategy.
- Do not read the answer choices. Spend only a few seconds labeling each question with the appropriate skill/strategy.
During Reading
- Read the whole section of text that was assigned.
- As you read, underline or highlight any information that may help you answer the question.
- Have students answer questions independently.
- Use the process of elimination for any questions for which you are not positive of the answer.
After Reading
- Prove all of your answers by underlining or copying evidence from the text. Go back and check your work. Do your answers make sense? Can you prove each answer?
- Share your answers with the group. Use text evidence to explain why you think an answer is correct.
-
Guidance for Questions 5 and 8:
- For Question #5: After identifying answer choice “C” as correct, engage students in a discussion around the sarcastic nature of the author’s statement. Ask, "Why didn’t the author simply say that he or she didn’t believe that the U.S. fulfilled its promise?" Extend the discussion by considering answer choice “D.” Discuss the distinction between sarcasm and humor.
- For Question #8: This question is designed to assess students’ understanding of both the purpose for and main idea of this passage. Allow several students to give and explain their answers, encouraging meaningful, text-based debate.
TIP:
Build Student Vocabulary enforcing
Texts & Materials
Standards Alignment
(To see all of the ReadWorks lessons aligned to your standards, click here.)
How do you get to segregation packet? I noticed someone asked in 2016? I did not see a response. Is there a trick I am not noticing? Thanks.
Thanks for sending along your question! To find the Student Packet, please visit the unit page here: http://www.readworks.org/lessons/grade5/maniac-magee
Scroll down to the Teacher and Student Materials section and click on the title, "Teacher and Student Materials." Under this section you will find the Student Packet and other materials for this unit. Thanks!
On pages 14-15 of the student packet, you will find the text, "Segregation: Past or Present?" Let us know if you have any other questions. Thank you!
Where are the student packets located?
Thanks for sending along your question! To find the Student Packet, please visit the unit page here: http://www.readworks.org/lessons/grade5/maniac-magee
Scroll down to the Teacher and Student Materials section and click on the title, "Teacher and Student Materials." Under this section you will find the Student Packet and other materials for this unit. Thanks!
Super Plan !!! Directly aligned with CCSS!
Submitted by B. Lavergne - 03-07-2016
I can't get to the passage Segregation: Past or Present?. I tried clicking on the link but it just keeps sending me back to the same page.
Thanks for sending along your question! To find the Student Packet, please visit the unit page here: http://www.readworks.org/lessons/grade5/maniac-magee
Scroll down to the Teacher and Student Materials section and click on the title, "Teacher and Student Materials." Under this section you will find the Student Packet and other materials for this unit. Thanks!
On pages 14-15 of the student packet, you will find the text, "Segregation: Past or Present?" Let us know if you have any other questions. Thank you!
Great plan!